It had been far too long since we’d last seen our friends Melissa and Scott out in Irvine, California. We actually tried to visit back in December 2024, but life had other plans and that trip never happened. Fast‑forward a few years, and we finally carved out time to make it happen this March. When we first started planning, it was just going to be Annie and me, so all of our initial bookings were for two. Later on, we decided to bring our daughter Rory along, and by that point prices had climbed. So if you notice multiple airfare reservations in this post, that’s the reason.
Airfare
When I started searching for flights on American Airlines to Orange County, the numbers came in right where I expected for a warm‑weather destination in March. Round trip cash fares hovered around $417 per person, while an award ticket would have set me back 38,000 miles. Not terrible, not amazing — just typical spring pricing. By the time I booked Rory’s ticket a few weeks later, the round trip cash price had risen to a ridiculous $613!


But here’s where a little strategy can make a big difference. Instead of locking myself into a simple round‑trip search, I broke the itinerary into one‑way segments and widened the net to include partner airlines. That’s often where the real gems hide, and in this case, it opened the door to far better options.
Chicago to Orange County


For our flight out to California, American Airlines was selling the 8 a.m. departure for $259 or 22,500 AAdvantage (AA) miles. That worked out to a weak redemption value of just 1.15 cents per mile ($259 / 22,500 miles), so using AA miles didn’t make much sense. I started looking for alternatives and remembered I still had a $50 Chase Travel credit to use.

Because I hold the Chase Sapphire Preferred card, my Chase Ultimate Rewards (UR) points are worth 1.25 cents each when booking through Chase Travel. Instead of paying cash for two tickets or burning 45,000 AA miles, I booked the flights through Chase. After applying the $50 credit, the total came to about $467. Using the 1.25‑cent portal rate, I only had to redeem 37,000 UR points and pay the extra $4.48 out of pocket.
Booking through Chase and using points saved me $512.50 and gave me better value than using AA miles.
Orange County to Chicago
One the way home, both the cash fare and the number of miles required were lower. American Airlines had a mid‑day return flight priced at $214 or 15,500 AAdvantage miles per person. That worked out to a better redemption value than the outbound flight at 1.38 cents per mile ($214 / 15,500 miles). At first glance, it looked like an easy decision.
But this is exactly why checking partner programs matters. The same American Airlines flight was available through Alaska’s Atmos Rewards for just 12,500 points. So instead of spending 31,000 AA miles, I redeemed 25,000 Atmos points total for our two tickets.


That move saved us $391 (after taxes and fees) compared to paying cash and delivered stronger value than using AA miles. A perfect example of why flexible points and a quick partner search can make a big difference.
Hotel
Pendry Newport Beach
For the hotel, I wanted to take advantage of the Amex Platinum’s Fine Hotels + Resort (FHR) credit. FHR is an exclusive American Express travel program for eligible Platinum and Centurion cardholders, offering elite benefits at over 1,800 luxury properties worldwide, like complimentary breakfast, room upgrades, $100 property credits, and guaranteed 4 PM late checkout, even without hotel loyalty status. These perks, booked via Amex Travel, provide added value and a VIP experience at high-end hotels and resorts.

There were a few hotel options in Newport Beach that peaked my interest, but the Pendry Newport Beach seemed to be the best fit.

Hotel reviews praise its luxurious, contemporary design, excellent service and California-inspired ambiance. It has upscale amenities like a beautiful pool, spa, multiple dining options and family-friendly programs. Plus it’s conveniently located near Fashion Island with easy access to beaches and local attractions. It’s also only about 15 minutes to our friends house.


We first booked a queen room back in December for $1,544, and the $300 semi‑annual Amex credit hit our account a few days later. When we later decided Rory was joining the trip, I had to cancel that reservation and rebook a room with two double beds. I made the new booking in January and Amex issued another $300 credit. Since they never clawed back the original one, the total savings on this stay ended up being $600.
Rental Car
Rental cars were surprisingly affordable for our dates, and Budget came in with the best deal. I snagged an EV for just $207, which felt like a steal.

Newport Beach 2026 Redemption Table
| Retail Cost | Our Cost | Miles and Points Used | Points Source | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 one-way tickets from Chicago (ORD) to Orange County (SNA) | $259 per person ($517 total) | $4.48 | 37,000 UR points | - Citi AAdvantage credit cards - AAdvantage eShopping - Simply Miles |
| 1 one-way ticket from Chicago (ORD) to Orange County (SNA) | $511 | $5.60 (taxes and fees) | 35,000 AA miles | - Citi AAdvantage credit cards - AAdvantage eShopping - Simply Miles |
| 2 one-way tickets from Orange County (SNA) to Chicago (ORD) | $214 per person ($427 total) | $36 (taxes and fees) | 25,000 Atmos miles | - Hawaiian Airlines World Elite Mastercard - Atmos Rewards Summit Visa Infinite |
| 1 one-way ticket from Orange County (SNA) to Chicago (ORD) | $319 | $18 (taxes and fees) | 12,500 Atmos miles | - Hawaiian Airlines World Elite Mastercard - Atmos Rewards Summit Visa Infinite |
| 3 nights at Pendry Newport Beach | $514.58 per night + taxes ($1,544 total) | $944 | N/A | - Amex Platinum $300 hotel credit |
| 3 day car rental | $207 | $207 | N/A | N/A |
| Total | $3,525 | $1,215 | - 37,000 UR points - 35,000 AA miles -37,500 Atmos miles/strong> | - $2,310 in total savings - 66% off retail cost |
Bottom Line
This long‑overdue trip to see friends in Irvine turned into a great reminder of how far a little flexibility and points strategy can go. By mixing Chase Ultimate Rewards, Alaska Atmos points, and a smart partner search, we cut hundreds off airfare that had suddenly spiked. Pair that with a perfectly timed Fine Hotels + Resorts booking that triggered two $300 Amex credits and an inexpensive EV rental, and the whole getaway became a masterclass in squeezing maximum value out of every reservation.
Trip Report Index
- Using Points and Miles to get to Newport Beach
- Pendry Newport Beach






























